April 24, 2025
James Hardie Siding vs. LP SmartSide Siding: Which is Right for You?
Choosing the right siding for your Connecticut home is a major decision that impacts your home's appearance, durability, and value. With the state’s unpredictable weather - from humid summers to snowy winters - homeowners in towns like Newtown, Hartford, Stamford, Danbury or Norwalk need siding that can stand the test of time. Two of the most popular siding options today are James Hardie Siding and LP SmartSide Siding. But which one is better suited for your home?
What is James Hardie Siding?
James Hardie Siding, also known as Hardie Board, is a fiber cement siding product made from a blend of sand, cement, and cellulose fibers. It is renowned for its exceptional durability, fire resistance, and ability to withstand extreme climates.
Hardie is a trusted brand across the U.S., especially in Connecticut, where homeowners value materials that can handle wet, cold, and stormy conditions.
James Hardie Siding: Key Features
☆ Moisture & Rot Resistance
Fiber cement resists mold, mildew, and warping.
☆ Fire Resistance
James Hardie siding is non-combustible.
☆ Pest Resistance
Termites and carpenter ants cannot damage it.
☆ Climate-Specific Engineering
Engineered for Climate® technology ensures optimal performance in the Northeast.
☆ ColorPlus® Technology
Offers long-lasting color and fade resistance.
☆ Eco-Friendly
Made with sustainable materials and low-VOC finishes.
What is LP SmartSide Siding?
LP SmartSide Siding is made from engineered wood—a blend of wood fibers and resins treated with SmartGuard® technology to improve strength and durability. It’s a popular alternative to traditional wood siding due to its natural appearance and lower price point.
LP SmartSide Siding: Key Features
☆ Engineered Wood Core
Looks more like real wood than fiber cement.
☆ SmartGuard® Protection
Treated with waxes, resins, and zinc borate for added defense against moisture and pests.
☆ Lighter Weight
Easier to install, which can reduce labor costs.
☆ Impact Resistance
Performs well against minor dings and hail.
☆ Versatile Design
Available in a variety of styles and lengths.
James Hardie vs. LP SmartSide: A Detailed Comparison
James Hardie
1. Rot Resistance
Superior in wet climates like Connecticut; resists rot and warping.
2. Impact Resistance
Durable but may crack on strong impact.
3. Maintenance
Low-maintenance with ColorPlus® finish.
4. Ease of Repairs
Repairs can be more labor-intensive.
5. Cost Considerations
Higher initial cost but longer lifespan and lower maintenance.
6. Warranty
30-year limited warranty + 15-year finish warranty.
7. Aesthetic Options
Both offer beautiful styles—plank, shingle, board and batten—with various textures and colors. James Hardie’s ColorPlus® offers greater fade resistance.
8. Installation Process
Heavier, requires special tools and trained professionals like Superior Remodeling.
LP SmartSide
1. 🔽
Better than natural wood but can still absorb moisture over time.
2. 🔽
More flexible; better at resisting dents and dings.
3. 🔽
Requires repainting more often unless prefinished.
4. 🔽
Easier to cut and replace sections.
5. 🔽
Lower upfront cost but may need more upkeep.
6. 🔽
50-year prorated warranty + optional prefinished paint warranty
7. 🔽
Both offer beautiful styles—plank, shingle, board and batten—with various textures and colors.
8. 🔽
Easier to install, but still best left to skilled contractors for warranty validity.
Why Choose James Hardie Siding Services from Superior Remodeling in Connecticut?
At Superior Remodeling, we specialize in James Hardie siding installation throughout Connecticut, including Newtown, Hartford, Stamford, Danbury, Norwalk. Here's what sets us apart:
- Certified Installers
Our team is trained by James Hardie for expert installation.
- Local Expertise
We understand Connecticut's climate challenges and tailor solutions accordingly.
- Free Siding Consultations
Get personalized advice and accurate cost estimates.
- Competitive Pricing & Financing
Premium service that fits your budget.
- High Customer Satisfaction
We’re a top-rated siding contractor known for professionalism, reliability, and exceptional results.
Both James Hardie Siding and LP SmartSide have their strengths. But if you’re looking for maximum durability, fire resistance, and weather protection for your Connecticut home, James Hardie is the superior choice—especially when installed by Superior Remodeling. Our team is ready to help you enhance your home's beauty and protection with expert siding services.
Contact Superior Remodelers today for a free estimate today and get the siding of your dreams. If you aren’t ready to speak with someone, don’t hesitate to fill out the online form on our website for a no obligation assessment.
Get a Free Estimate for Your Project
Contact us for a FREE estimate for your home improvement project. Call us or fill out the contact form on this page. We will get back to you shortly.
- Call us: 888-330-8148
- Visit Our Showroom: 3 Simm Lane Suite 3N Newtown, CT 06470
